#MeToo men want to be forgiven, but what of the careers of their casualties?
Yes, they did something wrong. But the punishment is out of proportion. They have apologised, they have promised to change. Isn’t it time we forgave some of the men brought down by #MeToo?
It’s an important question – one that anyone interested in justice should ask. Lately, the rate of asking has picked up pace. In an interview with Piers Morgan last week, Kevin Spacey sobbed at the treatment he had suffered, even as... more#MeToo men want to be forgiven, but what of the careers of their casualties?
Yes, they did something wrong. But the punishment is out of proportion. They have apologised, they have promised to change. Isn’t it time we forgave some of the men brought down by #MeToo?
It’s an important question – one that anyone interested in justice should ask. Lately, the rate of asking has picked up pace. In an interview with Piers Morgan last week, Kevin Spacey sobbed at the treatment he had suffered, even as he conceded that his accusers – one or two of them – had been telling the truth.
“There has been overreach by the media… but by your own admission, your behaviour was extremely inappropriate,” Morgan summarises, towards the end of the segment. “Sometimes it was non-consensual.”
“I am not going to behave that way [again],” replies Spacey, “and now we are at a place where: OK, what next? I am trying to seek a path to redemption.”
A similar remark appeared elsewhere last week – this time by a feminist writer in the New York Times – after the death of Morgan Spurlock, another man cancelled by #MeToo after he admitted harassing a colleague. “I can’t shake the feeling that nearly seven years after MeToo,” she writes, “we still haven’t found a way for men who want to make amends to do so meaningfully.”
It is troubling to see people ostracised, brutally and without due process, and with seemingly no hope of salvation. No fairminded person wants to live in a world like this. But as we ask whether perfect justice has been served when it comes to #MeToo’s powerful men, we should consider if we are missing part of the narrative. We used to ostracise their victims.
A prominent female #MeToo activist in China has been handed a five-year jail sentence for "subversion against the state".
Sophia Huang Xueqin was convicted and sentenced on Friday, nearly 10 months after she went on trial.
Labour activist Wang Jianbing, who stood trial with Ms Huang, was sentenced to three years and six months in prison.
Ms Huang, 36, had been one of the most prominent voices in China's #MeToo space, reporting ground-breaking s... moreChinese #MeToo journalist jailed for five years
A prominent female #MeToo activist in China has been handed a five-year jail sentence for "subversion against the state".
Sophia Huang Xueqin was convicted and sentenced on Friday, nearly 10 months after she went on trial.
Labour activist Wang Jianbing, who stood trial with Ms Huang, was sentenced to three years and six months in prison.
Ms Huang, 36, had been one of the most prominent voices in China's #MeToo space, reporting ground-breaking stories about sexual abuse victims.
She had also spoken out about the misogyny and sexism she faced in Chinese newsrooms.
Chinese authorities have not made it clear how the two stood accused of subversion. The trial was a closed-door hearing.
But their supporters say they were detained because they hosted regular meetings and forums for young people to discuss social issues.
Ms Huang had been on her way to take up a UK-government sponsored masters scholarship at the University of Sussex when she was detained at the airport in the city of Guangzhou in 2021.
Mr Wang, 40, was with her at that time.
Supporters say both have endured months of solitary confinement during their pre-detention custody, which lasted for nearly 1,000 days. Their trial only began in September 2023.
A BBC Eye investigation in 2022 found that both were being held in solitary confinement, detained in secret locations known as 'black jails'.
In 2021, amid Covid lockdowns and growing public anger, Chinese authorities launched a crackdown on several activists working across different fields.
"Their efforts and dedication to labour, women's rights, and the broader civil society won't be negated by this unjust trial, nor will society forget their contributions," said the campaign group Free Huang Xueqin and Wang Jianbing.
"On the contrary, as oppression persists and injustice grows, more activists like them will continue to rise."
Amnesty International on Friday called the convictions "malicious and totally groundless".
"[They] show just how terrified the Chinese government is of the emerging wave of activists who dare to speak out to protect the rights of others," said Amnesty International’s China Director Sarah Brooks.
"#MeToo activism has empowered survivors of sexual violence around the world, but in this case, the Chinese authorities have sought to do the exact opposite by stamping it out."
It is unclear if the time already served by the pair will go towards reducing their sentence.
Public reaction to Ms Huang's trial has previously been mixed - with some online decrying the case while others critical of the feminist movement welcomed it.
Many advocates for gender rights and social causes in China choose to remain anonymous online.
Often they have been accused of being "agents of hostile western forces" by state media and nationalists on the internet.
AREC is a global research organisation headquartered in Sheffield and now launching in the Shenzhen region of China. This video serves as an introduction to their work.
Find out more about our...